Passing dental school and gaining your qualifications to practice dentistry is a remarkable milestone in any dentist’s career. But just as impressive a change is purchasing and taking possession of your own dental clinic. Now you aren’t just focused on practicing to the best of your ability, you’re also taking on the responsibility of running the clinic and all the myriad responsibilities that come with it (from accurate record-keeping of patient records to handling licences and permits). While the clinical side of dentistry might be familiar territory for you by now, the legal and financial intricacies of acquiring a practice can be daunting, especially for first-time dental clinic buyers.

For many associates, the excitement of owning your dental clinic often takes a backseat to scrutinizing the purchase in detail (which is itself a necessary part of the purchase that deserves your full attention). It pays to remember that a dental practice purchase isn’t just a transaction of equipment and patient files. You are acquiring a living, breathing business entity, one with existing liabilities, obligations, and potential risks. Navigating this process requires a strategic approach rooted in sound legal principles.

Here are the essential legal considerations every associate must handle when purchasing their first dental clinic.

1. Assemble a Specialized Advisory Team

Before you sign any documents or view any statements, step one to searching for any available practice opportunities is to assemble a team of advisors who specialize specifically in the dental industry. A generalist lawyer or accountant may not have a sufficient familiarity with the nuances of dental practice valuations, chart audits, or the specific regulatory requirements of provincial dental colleges to guide you through this purchase.

You require a lawyer who understands the unique structure of dental transactions, such as how to properly value goodwill versus tangible assets. Similarly, you’ll need a specialized accountant on the team to advise on the tax implications of an asset sale versus a share sale. This team ensures that the structure of the deal protects your interests and maximizes your tax efficiency from day one.

2. The Letter of Intent (LOI)

Once you have identified a potential practice, the first formal legal step is usually the Letter of Intent (LOI). While often non-binding, the LOI is a critical document that sets the framework for the final Purchase and Sale Agreement. The letter outlines the purchase price, the closing date, and the general terms of the deal.

It is vital to treat the LOI with importance. A poorly drafted LOI can create ambiguity which can lead to disputes later in the negotiation. One thing to note is that the LOI must include no-shop clauses, which prevent the seller from entertaining other offers while you conduct your due diligence. Furthermore, the LOI should clearly state whether you are purchasing the shares of a professional corporation or the assets of the practice; take note that the legal and tax consequences of each differ significantly in Canada.

3. Comprehensive Due Diligence

It always pays to do your due diligence, and that’s doubly true of when acquiring a dental practice. Due diligence in this case consists of the investigative phase of the purchase. From a legal perspective, this demands more than simply checking the condition of the dental chairs or the sterilization centre. You must take steps to verify the legal standing of the practice.

This involves a detailed chart audit to verify the active patient count; take the time to check and verify it yourself rather than relying on the total number of files. The files themselves may include patients who have not visited in years, and so a little extra effort goes a long way toward confirming an accurate patient count. You must also conduct searches for liens or encumbrances on the equipment to ensure the seller has clear title to the assets they are selling. If the practice is a corporation, your lawyer will also need to review the corporate minute book to ensure all corporate filings are up to date and that the corporation is in good standing.

4. Scrutinizing the Commercial Lease

Finding the funding needed to pay for equipment and premises is one thing, dealing with the premises lease is another. The premises lease is often the most overlooked yet dangerous aspect of a dental practice purchase. You cannot move a dental practice easily; the cost of leasehold improvements (such as plumbing, lead-lined walls, and cabinetry) can be immense. Therefore, security of tenure is paramount.

Your lawyer must review the existing lease to ensure there is a remaining term (plus renewal options) that matches the amortization period of your bank loan. If the lease expires in three years but your loan is for ten, you are in a precarious position. Furthermore, watch for demolition clauses; these allow a landlord to terminate the lease early if they plan to redevelop the building. These clauses are common in growing urban centres and can destroy the value of your practice overnight if not properly negotiated or insured against.

5. Managing Employment Obligations

In Canada, employment laws regarding the sale of a business are strict. Generally, when you buy a practice, you may be deemed a "successor employer." What this means is that you could inherit the employees' years of service, which impacts their entitlements to vacation pay and severance.

If you purchase the shares of a corporation, the employer remains the same in the eyes of the law, and you inherit all past liabilities, including potential wrongful dismissal claims or unpaid overtime. If you purchase the assets, you technically offer new employment to the staff. However, Canadian courts often view the employment as continuous if the business operates without interruption. It is crucial to have written employment contracts in place for all staff members before closing the deal to clearly define termination notice periods and limit your future liability.

6. Restrictive Covenants and Non-Competes

The primary value of a dental practice lies in its goodwill, the reputation and patient loyalty built by the selling dentist. It takes years of work and service to your patients, diagnosing and treating any ailment to securing consent for any and all medical procedures, to build. To protect this investment, you must ensure the Purchase and Sale Agreement contains robust restrictive covenants.

These typically include a non-compete clause and a non-solicitation clause. A non-compete clause prevents the seller from practicing dentistry within a specific radius (e.g., 5 to 10 kilometres) for a certain period (e.g., 3 to 5 years). A non-solicitation clause prevents the seller from contacting patients or staff to draw them away to a new location. However, these clauses must also be reasonable in scope and duration to be enforceable in court. If they are too broad, a judge may strike them down entirely, and therefore leave you with no protection.

7. The Associate Agreement for the Seller

In many transactions, the selling dentist stays on as an associate for a transition period. This can be excellent for patient retention, as it allows for a "warm handoff" to the new owner. However, the legal relationship shifts: you are now the boss, and they are the employee or contractor.

This relationship requires a clear Associate Agreement. It should outline the selling dentist’s compensation (usually a percentage of collections or production), their hours, and their specific duties. Crucially, it must grant you, the owner, the final say on clinical philosophy and practice management to prevent friction. This agreement ensures that the transition period facilitates growth rather than creating a power struggle within the clinic.

Becoming a practice owner is a bold new step on your dental practice path, one that offers professional autonomy and financial growth. However, the process is also laden with legal responsibilities that require careful attention. By taking the time to understand exactly what it is you’ll face, you can help mitigate risk and build a solid foundation for your new business. With the right legal guidance and a thorough approach to the transaction, you can step into ownership with confidence, ready to lead your practice to long-term success.

Navigating the complexities of the healthcare industry requires a legal partner who understands your unique challenges. Health Law Firm provides comprehensive legal assistance designed to protect your interests and ensure full regulatory compliance. Contact Health Law Firm today at (416) 640-0508 to discover how we can support your practice.

News

From Associate to Owner: A Lawyer's Tips on Handling Your First Dental Clinic Purchase